Steel Roofing vs. Asphalt Shingles: Cost & Durability

If you’re in the early stages of planning a roof replacement at your home or business in Michigan and you’re not sure which roofing type is the right choice for you, the team at Lifetime Roofing would love to provide you with the guidance you need. When you turn to us for your project, you’ll love the top-of-the-line options we have to offer, as well as the unparalleled installation work we provide with each job we do. But how will you decide between our steel roofing and asphalt shingles? By the end of this blog, you’ll have a clearer idea of which one you prefer for your property. Let us explain. 

Understanding the Difference Between Steel Roofing & Asphalt Shingles

Before diving into the cost and durability comparisons between steel roofing and asphalt shingles, you’ll want to make sure you have a clear understanding of the options available to you. Typically made from galvanized steel, steel roofing comes in a variety of styles that can mimic traditional roofing materials. Not only that, but these roofs are known for their strength, weather resistance, and longevity.

As for asphalt shingle roofing, this material is made with fiberglass mats that are coated with asphalt and mineral granules. These roofs are extremely common in Michigan and throughout the U.S. thanks to their affordability and aesthetic versatility. With so many colors and styles available to choose between, you can feel confident that you’ll find the ideal look for your property. 

Cost Comparison: Steel Roofing vs. Asphalt Shingles

When it comes down to a direct comparison between the cost of steel roofing and asphalt shingles, there is plenty to consider. Of course, you’ll want to make sure your new roof fits within your budget, but it’s also important to consider more than just the short-term investment in your roofing upgrade. Think about the long-term value you could be getting with either choice, and that will help you come to a better, more informed decision for your property. Here’s what to keep in mind regarding:

Upfront Costs

When you’re looking at the initial costs of steel roofing and asphalt shingles, you’ll find that the latter will be more affordable. So, if you’re working with a limited budget or finding yourself in a situation where you simply need the better short-term investment, you may opt for asphalt shingles. Not only are the materials themselves more cost-effective, but the installation costs are lower, too.

On the other hand, a steel roofing system is going to cost more to begin with. The materials cost more, and the installation requires specialized expertise, which can lead to higher labor costs as well. At the same time, the overall cost will also depend on a variety of other factors, including the size of your roof and its complexity. 

Long-Term Costs

Whereas asphalt shingle roofing costs less up front, there can be higher long-term costs associated with this roofing type. Michigan’s weather can be tough on asphalt shingles, causing cracks, curls, granule loss, and moisture damage. And with that being the case, you may have to deal with more frequent repairs, which can become costly. Not only that, but you’re likely to need a new roof again sooner than you might with another roofing option.

The flip side of that is the fact that while steel roofing is costlier to start, its ability to withstand the elements that Michigan is known for can make it a better investment in the long run. You’ll need fewer and less frequent repairs, plus the longevity of steel roofs means you’ll have a longer wait for another replacement. In fact, depending on where you are in your life or how long you plan to own your property, one of these roofs could be the last you’ll ever buy.

Energy Efficiency Costs

Outside of the costs associated with these roofing materials themselves, they also differ when it comes to what they can do for your property’s energy costs. Because asphalt shingles are more likely to absorb heat from the sun, it can create a hotter environment that requires more from your HVAC system in order to maintain a steady, comfortable temperature.

Steel roofing, though, reflects solar heat rather than absorbing it. So, with that in mind, you might find that one of these roofs is going to contribute more to your property’s energy efficiency. Not only does saving energy help the environment, but you may also see savings on your heating and cooling costs longer term as well.

Durability Comparison: Steel Roofing vs. Asphalt Shingles

While we’ve briefly touched on the varying levels of durability and longevity that steel roofing and asphalt shingles can provide for your Michigan property, it’s worth a deeper dive to help you find the better choice for your situation. There are different threats you’ll need your roof to prove its durability against, such as:

Freeze-Thaw Cycles

Roofing in Michigan is bound to be threatened by the constant freeze-thaw cycles that Michigan winters are known for. So, how do these roofs respond when it comes to snow or ice freezing up and thawing out on their surfaces? Steel roofing expands and contracts, allowing it to maintain its structural integrity year after year. Asphalt shingles are more vulnerable to these temperature fluctuations, with freeze-thaw cycles having the potential to cause cracks and gaps in the roof and create the risk for leaks.

Wind, Rain, & Storms

Steel roofing is known to resist wind and storm damage, especially with proper installation. Well-fastened steel panels create a tight, secure barrier that you can rely on to remain intact and avoid lifting and allowing water in. Asphalt shingles also offer strong performance against the elements, though their durability will decrease over time. Strong storms can eventually lift or tear shingles, which leads to an exposed roof deck and the risk of more costly damage.

General Wear & Tear

When it comes to general wear and tear and the expected lifespans of these roofing options, you’ll undoubtedly find that steel roofing will typically last much longer. With a lifespan that can stretch over several decades, a steel roof is bound to provide better longevity than asphalt shingles, which are going to last around 15 to 25 years.

The Team to Turn to for Premium Steel Roofing & Top-Notch Asphalt Shingles

Whether you’d prefer a strong and long-lasting steel roofing system at your property in Michigan or you’d like to go with the more affordable, shorter-term option in asphalt shingles, you can expect excellence when you partner with Lifetime Roofing. We are proud of the high-quality systems we offer and the expertise with which we install them, and we’d love to be there for you when you need us at your residential or commercial property in Michigan.

If now is the right time to partner with Lifetime Roofing for your new roof, contact us today. We’d love to get your project started with a free estimate.